Accession: 154.24.022
Editorial Title: John Henry Keene to Mary Baker Eddy, May 17, 1904
Author: John Henry Keene 
Recipient: Mary Baker Eddy 
Date: May 17, 1904
Manuscript Description: Handwritten by John Henry Keene on unlined paper from Baltimore, Maryland.
Archival Note: This article includes an attached news clipping. See original.
Final Edits
Original Document

Click image to magnify
Full
Back
Close
View Document
View Image
154.24.022
-
Reproduced from the archive of The Mary Baker Eddy Library
Dear Mrs Eddy,

Your application of Magna Charta to the Board of Education, and Christian Science, shews that eternal vigilance is the price of liberty.

In an age of polite learning, and scientific research, certainly Christian ScienceAs Written:C. S. should stand for a higher standard than literary As Written: liteary indigence of a squalid character.

The Atlantic MonthlyEditorial Note: The Atlantic Monthly, now The Atlantic, began as a magazine for literary and cultural commentary, first published in Boston, Massachusetts, in 1857. address itself to those popular educators, from whom the masses derive their intellectual moral and religious doctrines be they good or bad– Dr Churchoman's scholarly articleEditorial Note: This is a reference to an article by Dr. John W. Churchman, titled "Christian Science," which was published in the April 1904 issue of The Atlantic Monthly. though As Written: thogh it over-honored As Written: overhonered no one of superiority of talent As Written: tallent furnished an arsenal of skepticism As Written: scepticsm and "deadly enquiries As Written: enqires , and abundant ammunitionAs Written:amunition; and it was well calculated to shake the [?] Unclear or illegible  of Christian ScienceAs Written:C. S. in the opinion of the uninstructed.

The reply to my mind, the defense was complete, and furnished by the [?] Unclear or illegible  itself, provided the weapon had been wielded with a strong arm – that response should have appeared to the readers of the Atlantic Monthly. McCrackan (I think) silenced the batteries of Artemas Ward effectually (Mark Twain).Editorial Note: This may be a reference to four articles by Mark Twain about Christian Science, published in the North American Review beginning in December 1902. William Denison McCrackan responded with an article in the March 1903 issue of the North American Review. He replied in the same Journal.

The awakening of sleepers and thinkers to the unfoldments of Christian ScienceAs Written:C. S. is approaching by rapid strides to a sharp crisis– In this view, I should fall far short of my duty, did I not from a wider field of survey, frankly confess to you that I cannot conceive a more disastrous blow to this budding unfoldment than Farlows answer to Churchman – I am a patient long suffering reader of twaddle of all kinds, daily, but I could not stand this stuff for five minutes- Churchmans letter has a significant tendency towards an atmosphere of rationalistic negation but Farlows deals in common places, vapid dregs, an unwholesome agglomeration of mere words. Farlow, has no one of the gifts of literary As Written: liteary expression, no penetrating rationalism, no scholarship no faculty of philosophic meditation – no large organic or constructive conception of Christian ScienceAs Written:C. S. such as is displayed by many of your lectures, notably, Youngs, whose Boston lectureEditorial Note: A report of a lecture by Bicknell Young, given in Symphony Hall, Boston, Massachusetts, on April 14, appeared in the April 30, 1904 issue of the Christian Science Sentinel under the title "Semi-annual Lecture of the Mother Church." recently appeared in the Sentinel. an answer that overflows column upon column, of long drawn common places wearies fatigues disgusts: Not one of the salient As Written: saelient points argued and raised by Churchman are met by Farlow. The result is a disaster to Christian ScienceAs Written:C. S.

That any measures should be taken to answer Churchman, at the time admits of grave consideration as Farlow says, Christian ScienceAs Written:C. S. is not "a "competitive" system". It is Christs'. What are the self respecting public to think of a Defender of Christian ScienceAs Written:C. S. who says

[*]Editorial Note: News clipping begins.[*]Gap: letters.Reason: text cut off.

The tone of the doctor's dissertation is comparatively temperate. True, he employs such terms as "inaccuracy," "ignorance," "charlatanry," and "theft"; but one does not mind epithets coming from a gentleman and hurled in a kindly manner."

If Christian Science is "utterly [*]Gap: letters.Reason: text cut off.[*]Editorial Note: News clipping ends.

I have not the patience to go through this melancholy performance.

It is exasperating to cultivated minds.

Momentarily, it over clouds Christian ScienceAs Written:C. S.

What must the cultivated Public think of a ScientistEditorial Note: Christian Scientist, of whom the virtual head, the real Director of its PublicationsEditorial Note: Committee on Publication, has little or no knowledge of the grammatical forms of the English language. What is needed is a writer who can write, what an enquiring age, should bind about their necks, and write upon the tablets of their heartsProv 3:3 Let not mercy and truth forsake thee: bind them about thy neck; write them upon the table of thine heart: . From one end of Farlows to another there is little but erudities, and common places, quotat[*]Gap: letters.Reason: page rip. & the scriptures which all are familiar with. When you wanted Christian ScienceAs Written:C. S. set forth with force of reasoning, and the lustre of eloquence.

Pardon my intrusion– Faithfully [?] Unclear or illegible 
John Henry Keene
154.24.022
-
Reproduced from the archive of The Mary Baker Eddy Library
Dear Mrs Eddy,

Your application of Magna Charta to the Board of Education, and Christian Science, shews that eternal vigilance is the price of liberty.

In an age of polite learning, and scientific research, certainly C. S.Expanded:Christian Science should stand for a higher standard than liteary Corrected: literary indigence of a squalid character.

The Atlantic MonthlyEditorial Note: The Atlantic Monthly, now The Atlantic, began as a magazine for literary and cultural commentary, first published in Boston, Massachusetts, in 1857. address itself to those popular educators, from whom the masses derive their intellectual moral and religious doctrines be they good or bad– Dr Churchoman's scholarly articleEditorial Note: This is a reference to an article by Dr. John W. Churchman, titled "Christian Science," which was published in the April 1904 issue of The Atlantic Monthly. thogh Corrected: though it overhonered Corrected: over-honored no one of superiority of tallent Corrected: talent furnished an arsenal of scepticsm Corrected: skepticism and a "deadliey enqires Corrected: enquiries , and [?] Unclear or illegible  abundant amunitionCorrected:ammunition; and it was well calculated to shake the [?] Unclear or illegible  of C. S.Expanded:Christian Science in the opinion of the uninstructed.

The reply to my mind, the defense was complete, and furnished by the [?] Unclear or illegible  itself, provided the weapon had been [?] Unclear or illegible  wielded with a strong arm – that response should have appeared to the readers of the Atlantic Monthly. McCrackan (I think) silenced [?] Unclear or illegible  the batteries of Artemas Ward effectually (Mark Twain).Editorial Note: This may be a reference to four articles by Mark Twain about Christian Science, published in the North American Review beginning in December 1902. William Denison McCrackan responded with an article in the March 1903 issue of the North American Review. He replied in the same Journal.

The awakening of sleepers and thinkers to the unfoldments of C. S.Expanded:Christian Science is approaching by rapid strides to a sharp crisis– In this view, I should fall far short of my duty, did I not from a wider field of survey, frankly confess to you that I cannot conceive a more disastrous blow to this budding unfoldment than Farlows answer to Churchman – I am a patient long suffering reader of twaddle of all kinds, daily, but I could not stand this stuff for five minutes- [?] Unclear or illegible  Churchmans letter has a significant tendency towards an atmosphere of rationalistic negation but Farlows deals in common places, vapid dregs, an unwholesome agglomeration of mere words. Farlow, has no one of the gifts of liteary Corrected: literary expression, no penetrating rationalism, no scholarship no faculty of philosophic meditation – no large organic or constructive conception of C. S.Expanded:Christian Science such as is displayed by many of your lectures, notably, Youngs, whose Boston lectureEditorial Note: A report of a lecture by Bicknell Young, given in Symphony Hall, Boston, Massachusetts, on April 14, appeared in the April 30, 1904 issue of the Christian Science Sentinel under the title "Semi-annual Lecture of the Mother Church." recently appeared in the Sentinel. [?] Unclear or illegible  an answer that overflows column upon column, of long drawn common places wearies fatigues disgusts: Not one of the saelient Corrected: salient points argued and raised by Churchman are met by Farlow. The result is a disaster to C. S.Expanded:Christian Science

That someany measures should be taken to answer Churchman, at the time admits of grave consideration as Farlow says, C. S.Expanded:Christian Science is not "a "competitive" system". It is Christs'. What are the self respecting public to think of a Defender of C. S.Expanded:Christian Science who says

[*]Editorial Note: News clipping begins.[*]Gap: letters.Reason: text cut off.he pronounces unheroic.

The tone of the doctor's dissertation is comparatively temperate. True, he employs such terms as "inaccuracy," "ignorance," "charlatanry," and "theft"; but one does not mind epithets coming from a gentleman and hurled in a kindly manner."

If Christian Science is "utterly [*]Gap: letters.Reason: text cut off.[*]Editorial Note: News clipping ends.

I have not the patience to go through this melancholy performance.

It is exasperating to cultivated minds.

Momentarily, it over clouds C. S.Expanded:Christian Science

What must the cultivated Public think of a Scien [?] Unclear or illegible tistEditorial Note: Christian Scientist, of whom the virtual head, the real Director of its PublicationsEditorial Note: Committee on Publication, has little or no knowledge of the grammatical forms of the English language. What is needed is a writer who can write, what an enquiring age, should bind about their neeksnecks, and write upon the tablets of their heartsProv 3:3 Let not mercy and truth forsake thee: bind them about thy neck; write them upon the table of thine heart: . From one end of Farlows to another there is little but erudities, and common places, quotat[*]Gap: letters.Reason: page rip. & the scriptures which all are familiar with. When you wanted [?] Unclear or illegible  C. S.Expanded:Christian Science set forth with force of reasoning, and the lustre of eloquence.

Pardon my intrusion– Faithfully [?] Unclear or illegible 
John Henry Keene
 
View Image
 

Back Text

Shown for development purposes only
The Atlantic Monthly, now The Atlantic, began as a magazine for literary and cultural commentary, first published in Boston, Massachusetts, in 1857. This is a reference to an article by Dr. John W. Churchman, titled "Christian Science," which was published in the April 1904 issue of The Atlantic Monthly. News clipping begins. News clipping ends. This may be a reference to four articles by Mark Twain about Christian Science, published in the North American Review beginning in December 1902. William Denison McCrackan responded with an article in the March 1903 issue of the North American Review. A report of a lecture by Bicknell Young, given in Symphony Hall, Boston, Massachusetts, on April 14, appeared in the April 30, 1904 issue of the Christian Science Sentinel under the title "Semi-annual Lecture of the Mother Church." Christian Scientist Committee on Publication