Accession: L13467
Editorial Title: Mary Baker Eddy to Benjamin F. Atkinson, June 3, 1882
Author: Mary Baker Eddy 
Recipient: Benjamin F. Atkinson 
Annotator: Hanover P. Smith 
Date: June 3, 1882
Manuscript Description: Handwritten by Mary Baker Eddy on lined paper with edits by Eddy in purple ink. This letter also has a notation by Hanover P. Smith.
Editorial Note: This letter contains references to mental influences and mental malpractice, which, at the time of this letter, Eddy believed could harm her and those supporting her. Over time, however, she learned that it was crucial in dealing with mental malpractice to see evil as an impersonal lie and not to identify it with persons.
Final Edits
Original Document

Click image to magnify
Full
Back
Close
View Document
View Image
L13467
-
Reproduced from the archive of The Mary Baker Eddy Library

With the cold form of beloved husband lying on his bier in my desolated home I appeal to you once more, and if you are not darkened to the sense of the awful crimes I know you will stop them by every influence in your power.

I have power to discern the cause of his death, I never was mistaken in the mental cause in this case and what I say the future will declare, namely; that Edward J. Arnes has caused the death of my husbandEditorial Note: Mary Baker Eddy believed Asa Gilbert Eddy’s death was caused by the mental malpractice of Edward J. Arens and others. in connection with his cooperators so far as I can clearly discern in my diagnosis of the case.

In this awful hour, I sent for him that I might point to the silent lips and say to Mr. Arnes over his corpse, “thou art the manII Sam 12:7 ¶And Nathan said to David, Thou art the man. Thus saith the Lord God of Israel, I anointed thee king over Israel, and I delivered thee out of the hand of Saul; —and then ask him to remember what that dear one and I had done to save him from his own awful nature by our teachings.

How we sheltered him when he had no home and friends, how I took from my loving humane husband, hundreds of dollars to extricate him from peril that his own conduct, uninfluenced by us, had brought upon him. How I have suffered his gigantic frauds silently, taking not only our money falsely and breaking all his agreements to pay us, but still pursuing As Written: persuing, claiming as his own, my hard earned writings and labors, and last O! horrible to relate, in cold blood with malice afore thoughtEditorial Note: aforethought, taking from me all of earth I had to lose. Do you forget your sorrow at the thought of losing As Written: loosing your wife? and do you forget my pity and that I saved her to make happy your declining years? and have you no mercy for me if you can stay this bloodshed? and if not God will avenge it, tis’ but a little time before his justice will meet the hour. I never knew until As Written: untill after the birth, that your daughter was about to be a mother, and then I heard of her sufferings and took her into my mind to prevent any danger from the use of instruments: but today she did not send her wicked husband at my request to see mine in his shroud.

Yours in love and Truth
Mary B. G. Eddy.

Here I will say in half an hour after he knew my husband was killed, he attacked me, but I am well.

Handshift:Hanover P. SmithTrue Copy Attest

Hanover P. Smith

L13467
-
Reproduced from the archive of The Mary Baker Eddy Library

With my the cold form of beloved husband lying on his bier in my desolated home forever still I appeal to you once more, and if you are not darkened to the sense of the awful crimes I know you will stop them by every influence in your power.

I have power to discern the cause of his death, I never was mistaken in the mental cause in this case and what I say the future will declare, namely; that Edward J. Arnes has caused the death of my husbandEditorial Note: Mary Baker Eddy believed Asa Gilbert Eddy’s death was caused by the mental malpractice of Edward J. Arens and others. in connection with his cooperators so far as I can clearly discern in my diagnosis of the case.

In this awful hour, I sent for him that I might point to the silent lips and say to Mr. Arnes over his corpse, “thou art the manII Sam 12:7 ¶And Nathan said to David, Thou art the man. Thus saith the Lord God of Israel, I anointed thee king over Israel, and I delivered thee out of the hand of Saul; —and then ask him to remember what that dear one and I had done to save him from his own awful nature by our teachings.

How we sheltered him when he had no home and friends, how I took from my loving humane husband, hundreds of dollars to extricate him from peril that his own conduct, uninfluenced by us, had brought upon him. How I have suffered his gigantic frauds silently, taking not only our money falsely and breaking all his agreements to pay us, but still persuing, Corrected: pursuing claiming as his own, my hard earned writings and labors, and last O! horrible to relate, in cold blood with malice afore thoughtEditorial Note: aforethought, taking from me all of earth I had to lose. Do you forget your sorrow at the thought of loosing Corrected: losing your wife? and do you forget my pity and that I saved her to make happy your declining years? and have you no mercy for me if you can stay this bloodshed? and if not God will avenge it, tis’ but a little time before his justice will meet the hour. I never knew untill Corrected: until after the birth, that your daughter was about to be a mother, and then I heard of her sufferings and took her into my mind to prevent any danger from the use of instruments: but today she did not send her wicked husband at my request to see mine in his shroud.

Yours in love and Truth
Mary B. G. Eddy.

Here I will say in half an hour after he knew my husband was killed, he attacked me, but I am well.

Handshift:Hanover P. SmithTrue Copy Attest

Hanover P. Smith

 
View Image
 

Back Text

Shown for development purposes only
Mary Baker Eddy believed Asa Gilbert Eddy’s death was caused by the mental malpractice of Edward J. Arens and others. aforethought